Skip to content

Loafers vs. Lace-Ups: Which Men's Shoe Style Reigns Supreme?

When it comes to men's formal shoes, the choices are vast and varied. Among the most popular options are loafers and lace-ups, each with it’s unique charm and style. In this style showdown, we'll explore the world of formal shoes for men, comparing the ever-classic loafers with the versatile lace-up shoes, including derby, oxford, and brogue styles, as well as monk strap shoes, boots, and slip-on shoes. Let's dive into the details and find out which shoe style reigns supreme.

The Classic Appeal of Loafers

Versatility Personified

Loafers are the epitome of versatility in formal shoes for men. These slip-on wonders require no laces or buckles, making them incredibly convenient for those rushed mornings when every second counts. Whether you're heading to the office or attending a formal event, loafers effortlessly bridge the gap between casual and formal attire.

Business Casual

Ideal for Business Casual

Loafers are a go-to option for business casual attire. They pair exceptionally well with dress trousers, chinos, or even a well-fitted pair of jeans. The absence of laces lends a relaxed vibe, making them a comfortable choice for long days at the office or casual Fridays.

Loafers you should know

Types of Loafers you should know

Penny Loafers

Penny loafers are a timeless classic characterized by a diamond-shaped cutout on the saddle, where a small decorative "penny" or coin can be placed. They are a staple in men's footwear and offer a blend of sophistication and casual charm.

Tassel Loafers

Tassel Loafers

Tassel loafers are recognized by the decorative tassels on the vamp. These loafers exude a slightly more formal vibe compared to penny loafers, making them a great choice for dressier occasions.

men’s loafers

How should modern men style men’s loafers?

Casual Look:

For a relaxed, everyday style, pair loafers with jeans or chinos. Go for a slim-fit or straight-leg cut to keep the look sleek. Choose loafers in suede or soft leather for a more casual feel. Depending on your preference and the weather, you can wear them with or without socks.

Smart Casual:

To elevate your outfit, opt for loafers with a tailored pair of trousers or chinos. A button-up shirt or a smart polo shirt complements this look perfectly. Leather loafers for men, especially in darker hues for instance black or brown, work well for smart casual attire.

Business Casual:

 For a business casual setting, loafers for men can be a comfortable yet stylish choice. Pair them with dress pants and a blazer, or a suit for a less formal business environment.

Sock Choice:

 If you choose to wear socks, ensure they are appropriate for the occasion. For a more formal look, match your socks to your trousers. For a casual look, you can experiment with no-show socks or even patterned socks for a pop of colour.

The Timeless Allure of Lace-Ups

Oxford Shoes

Oxford shoes are the quintessential lace-up formal shoes for men. They are known for their closed lacing system, where the shoelace eyelets are stitched under the vamp. This design not only looks sleek but also offers a secure fit. Oxford shoes are a top choice for black-tie events and formal business settings.

Derby Shoes

Derby Shoes

Derby shoes, also known as bluchers, are another lace-up option. They feature an open lacing system, with the eyelets sewn on top of the vamp. This design allows for a more adjustable fit and makes derby shoes slightly less formal than oxfords. They are an excellent choice for business attire and can be dressed up or down.

Brogue Shoes

Brogue shoes, available in both oxford and derby styles, are characterized by decorative perforations (broguing) along the edges and sometimes on the toe cap. These perforations add a touch of detail and style to the shoes. Brogues are suitable for both formal and semi-formal occasions, making them a versatile addition to your shoe collection.

Monk Strap Shoes

Monk strap shoes offer a unique alternative to traditional lace-ups. They feature one or two straps (single monk or double monk) with buckles instead of laces. Monk strap shoes strike a balance between formality and flair, making them a favourite among fashion-forward individuals.

the lace-ups for men

How to style the lace-ups for men?

Match the Occasion:

The type of lace-ups you wear should match the formality of the occasion. For instance, oxfords are more formal and suitable for business or formal events, while derbies or brogues can be more casual.

Coordinate with Your Outfit:

Your shoes should complement your outfit. Black men lace-ups are classic and go well with most formal attire, especially black, grey, or navy suits. On the other hand, brown lace-up shoes for men are more versatile and can be worn with a variety of shades, including lighter suits.

Consider the Season:

In warmer months, lighter colours and materials like suede can be a stylish choice. In colder months, darker, more durable leather shoes are appropriate.

Socks Matter:

The choice of socks can add a subtle flair to your outfit. For a professional look, match your socks to the colour of your trousers. For a more casual or fashionable statement, choose patterned or colourful socks.

Experiment with Styles:

Don't be afraid to try different styles of lace-ups like wingtips, cap-toes, or even coloured laces for a unique look.

Casual Pairing:

For a more casual look, you can pair less formal lace-ups with jeans or chinos. Just make sure the shoes are not too formal for the outfit.


Comfort is Crucial:

Comfort should never be compromised. If you're not comfortable in your shoes, it will affect your overall appearance and confidence.

The Battle of Formality

Loafers vs. Oxford Shoes

When it comes to formality, Oxford shoes take the lead. Their closed-lacing system and sleek design make them the go-to choice for black-tie events and highly formal occasions. Loafers, while versatile, may not be the best choice for events where strict dress codes are enforced.

Loafers vs. Derby Shoes

Derby shoes offer a bit more versatility in terms of formality compared to loafers. While they can be worn in formal settings, they also work well with business casual and smart-casual outfits. Loafers, on the other hand, lean more towards the casual end of the spectrum.

Loafers vs. Brogue Shoes

Brogue shoes, whether oxfords or derby share a similar level of formality with loafers. Both can be dressed up or down, making them suitable for a range of occasions. The choice between them often comes down to personal style preference.

Loafers vs. Monk Strap Shoes

Monk strap shoes, particularly single monks, are often considered as formal as oxfords. Loafers may not match the same level of formality but can still hold their own in many professional settings. The choice depends on the specific dress code and your personal style.

The Final Verdict

In the battle of loafers vs. lace-ups, there is no clear winner. Each style has its unique charm and place in a man's wardrobe. The choice ultimately depends on your style, the dress code of the occasion, and your comfort level.

So, the next time you're faced with the choice of loafers or lace-ups, consider the occasion, your outfit, and your personal style. Whichever you choose, step out with confidence and make a statement with your footwear. After all, in the world of men's fashion, the right pair of shoes can elevate your entire look.